The Aberdeen City and Shire Thistle Awards rely on the expertise, integrity and commitment of our independent judging panel.

About our Judges

Each year, we invite experienced professionals from across tourism, hospitality, events and related sectors to contribute their knowledge to this respected regional awards programme.

Judging is a rewarding opportunity to support the industry, recognise excellence and help shape the future of tourism in Aberdeen City and Shire.

Role & Expectations
Role Overview

Judges play a vital role in maintaining the credibility and integrity of the awards.

As a judge, you will:

  • Sign up to the ACSTA Code of Conduct
    Review and score written submissions independently
  • Participate in structured judging discussions
  • Contribute to shortlisting decisions
  • Conduct mystery visits (where applicable)
  • Take part in face-to-face finalist interviews (individual categories)
  • Provide detailed written feedback via the online scoring platform

Judges are assigned to categories aligned with their sector expertise and must declare any conflicts of interest.

All judging is undertaken in confidence.
Expectations

To ensure fairness and professionalism, judges are required to:

  • Attend at least one in-person judging briefing session
  • Be available for face-to-face finalist interviews (where applicable)
  • Adhere strictly to non-negotiable judging deadlines
  • Provide comprehensive written comments at all stages of scoring
  • Complete finalist summary forms where required
  • Maintain strict confidentiality at all times
  • Refrain from publicly disclosing their judging role during the awards cycle
  • Never reveal shortlist or winner information prior to official announcements
  • Conduct themselves in a manner that does not bring the awards into disrepute

Judges are expected to approach all submissions objectively, fairly and without bias.

The role requires time commitment, professionalism and attention to detail.

Application Form

If you are interested in becoming a judge for the Aberdeen City and Shire Thistle Awards, please complete the online application form.
You will be asked to provide:

  • Contact details
  • Current role and organisation
  • Relevant sector expertise
  • Previous judging experience (if any)
  • A short statement outlining why you wish to be involved
  • Declaration of any potential conflicts of interest

Applications will be reviewed by the Steering Committee.

Successful applicants will be contacted directly and provided with further briefing information.